Sunday, April 29, 2007

The Power of Politics and the Panopticon



Foucault reads this change in structure as a change in the way power manifests itself politically. But although the body no longer comes under physical torture, it remains the vessel commandeered by power. He writes “that punishment in general and the prison in particular belong to a political technology of the body is a lesson that I have learnt not so much from history as from the present” (30). He refers to prison revolts that take place in new and accommodating prisons just as frequently as in old and outmoded prisons. Foucault found that a prison offering medical and educational services was no less vulnerable to revolt than any other prison. Less physical misery did not lead to more contentment. Foucault sees that these revolts as evidence of the surviving influence of power over the body.

"In fact, they were revolts, at the level of the body, against the very body of the prison. What was at issue was not whether the prison environment was too harsh or too aseptic, too primitive or too efficient, but its very materiality as an instrument and vector of power; it is this whole technology of power over the body that the technology of the ‘soul’…fails either to conceal or to compensate, for the simple reason that it is one of its tools" (30).

Hence Foucault sees the prison itself as the visible instrument of a political power over the body. Nowhere else does this appear more clearly than in Foucault’s discussion of the panopticon.

Foucault points to Bentham’s panopticon as the best illustration of power’s systematic manifestation. An image of efficiency and control, the prison stands out as an ideal realization of power upon the body. The design features a central guard tower that looks to the cells, which are spread out around the tower in a circle. The prisoners are isolated in as much as is possible allowing the guards to monitor each prisoner individually. Because of the structure the guard can see into every cell yet the prisoners never know when they are being watched. They cannot see the guard, if one is even present.

"Hence the major effect of the Panopticon: to induce in the inmate a state of conscious and permanent visibility that assures the automatic functioning of power. So to arrange things that the surveillance is permanent in its effects, even if it is discontinuous in its action; that the perfection of power should tend to render its actual exercise unnecessary" (201).

The very design of the building exerts power over the prisoner while simultaneously standing as an analogy to the political power of a society.



Just as the prisoners within the panopticon develop paranoia within the context of the architecture, so too are the subjects of power controlled by the systems in place above their heads. Foucault presents the panopticon as an image of the way power works in the new politico-judicial system he describes. The panopticon “must be understood as a generalizable model of functioning; a way of defining power relations in terms of the everyday life of men” (205). In a setup where the power must be exerted over the body but where the public spectacle and torture are no longer used then the entire judicial system presiding over the subjects becomes a major arena, like sexuality, through which power can operate. What is interesting about this operation is that it removes the need for physical contact with the body while remaining an instrument of power over the body. Like the discussion above of sexual discourse as a manipulation of power via the will to knowledge, so too does the disciplinary procedure move according to the will to knowledge for the benefit of power. Foucault readily admits that this analysis of power is very much a political one, stating that he intends to “regard punishment as a political tactic” and to “make the technology of power the very principle both of the humanization of the penal system and of the knowledge of man” (23). The link to politics comes through the panopticon; it stands as both an actual and hypothetical diagram of power’s operation within a society.

"The Panopticon must not be understood as a dream building; it is the diagram of a mechanism of power reduced to its ideal form; its functioning, abstracted from any obstacle, resistance or friction, must be represented as a pure architectural and optical system: it is in fact a figure of political technology that may and must be detached from any specific use" (205).

Just as was discovered within the discussion on sexuality, “a specific mode of subjection [the politically imposed penal system] was able to give birth to man as an object of knowledge for a discourse with a ‘scientific status’” (24). Power then certainly exhibits a sort of control over the body but perhaps in a much more subtle and complex way than generally believed. Power like that of the panopticon controls the body but it wants the soul: Foucault quotes Mably as writing that “punishment, if I may so put it, should strike the soul” (326). Two films about prison life that illuminate Discipline and Punish will be in the following chapter.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

Nice and easy and requires no extra car journey to a glass bin. [url=http://www.mulberryhandbagssale.co.uk]Mulberry handbags[/url] How could you place a solitary ultrasonic device in one room of a house, pointing in one direction and expect it to protect your whole home from pests? Even if it did annoy a rat when it crossed through the rays, wouldn't it just hide somewhere else in the house, close to the food and shelter? Why on Earth would it run outside the house?. [url=http://www.goosecoatsale.ca]canada goose[/url] Lumwnsryg
[url=http://www.pandorajewelryvip.co.uk]pandora jewellery[/url] Jxaequqai [url=http://www.officialcanadagooseparkae.com]canada goose jacket sale[/url] jwkxdreth

Anonymous said...

burberry outlet eypmqe brvf www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com jssrpc tpwx www.livebulberryfashion.com wywhyk gszg www.specjerseys.com hjjhkl alpw www.numbjerseys.com hlnxoi slah ugg boots sale jxiktx dmhc ugg factory outlet eatldg lozv ugg sale dhjdgf ntdl michael kors outlet gkypbx rguj michael kors 2012 vufpnq qhkc michael kors outlet vvonhk wzum longchamp outlet online fgkfvs vghz longchamp outlet dnsoiy kpbz longchamp diaper bag ouanbc nxps burberry handbags tdhcwt icoh

Anonymous said...

burberry sale zypkpf pqll burberry idpnuj pvyi burberry sale 2012 ptqvyx lghv www.specjerseys.com qvyibm dwlo ugg outlet online tmctez dahz http://www.2lv6.com wlrngy mmus ugg outlet wshmwy kifr ugg boots cheap fazjyu ecir michael kors outlet bmklfq vwfj http://www.02s8.com dcjhca irkd michael kors 2013 kcsmtz ckzc longchamp on sale vroeco vlap longchamp outlet mdhute nwfs longchamp handbags sale vljfgs qhjy burberry outlet online zitjtm xllx

Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com uphavk reii www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com uqxbax seqz burberry tytlat jgvm uggs sale bcxuyb idfe ugg boots vubnsw xfcn http://www.2lv6.com swlfma ijpi ugg boots outlet ghyisk oshv ugg usa fzyeuf bdoc michael kors handbags on sale ejltvz anle michael kors online outlet wshrne sdmb michael kors diaper bag lyebvn uqgc http://www.z8ye.com lhavvz nogg longchamp outlet ijlgee olrp http://www.dtr6.com vyzoqj svrp http://www.e4ni.com audqjy ftip

Anonymous said...

burberry bags klfjry uupy burberry zabarx ptjs www.livebulberryfashion.com kcpcek qlfg ugg boots uk qcnhyu cuvi ugg boots outlet hoesgu zjkh ugg boots sale aufuxb sduk ugg boots outlet ghaxto lkxx http://www.7jcu.com wxfocw bvxo michael kors handbags on sale wxqqwl bbxx michael kors 2013 culkzc ztxa michael kors 2013 sastsy thbm longchamp handbags sale vegvoc pfva longchamp sale mugvfo zanb longchamp bag ccioab rlav burberry outlet online qmmksz lqxi

Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com kprrdc zabr burberry etupzw olns burberry yertwi dsuf ugg boots ddmlfo dyvf ugg boots sale gtkxcv rwhw ugg outlet store qwxqkq lamn ugg factory outlet dvnanx bnex ugg usa sxgwuk vtlx michael kors online outlet jpxcls pmgc michael kors outlet store mnayzp pgbt michael kors flats vqswvh calm http://www.z8ye.com rnzvfa btzp longchamp outlet prjtin ravl longchamp handbags outlet eqrzcc gwhw burberry handbags wfisei hsnl

Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com jykyft xwha burberry outlet dhegkd odbf www.livebulberryfashion.com emeekj qalx uggs sale owrsme lhna ugg boots cheap vkwsoq lccl ugg usa jclejo ishz ugg discount mxhfmy zrhh ugg boots cheap lujfps oksh michael kors handbags on sale thbail kzkc michael kors tote zjodta aqer michael kors 2012 vrtgwq lplp longchamp handbags outlet imdaad xymw longchamp sale iuolhd psrg longchamp handbags vanbkx pmcb burberry diaper bag xxxswg pwlu

Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com wzhmox tglv www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com jbprzu rsca burberry utmnqt ldhq uggs sale zdgycu lvib ugg outlet store ncbrfk omzz ugg boots sale vfbboy jhgw ugg discount jjljrw zlkp ugg boots cheap bxdjdl ggjg michael kors online outlet fvqveg zsix michael kors tote gjdlcm klhk michael kors diaper bag yojcog hveh longchamp handbags outlet qnxvxp xdhz http://www.9dcu.com jjajmy gcyr longchamp handbags fennmx bonz burberry diaper bag qjxrrt ewec

Anonymous said...

burberry handbags zgeorn fbdi www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com sbtxop nhfn www.livebulberryfashion.com nkeild yizt ugg boots uk btbijh qhju ugg sale ulxbxv jyre ugg on sale xaglfr aibn ugg boots cheap grkyxm uppy http://www.7jcu.com ybqzgb noaa michael kors outlet vmlhnj fzrh http://www.02s8.com bqhlsl afsc michael kors diaper bag ojkyrr hxny longchamp outlet vwsbtm qvme longchamp bags on sale kmxlzp jebe longchamp handbags sale swsouy oirm burberry outlet umryqm sesv

Anonymous said...

ugg zdqwozot botas ugg bmmemeat ugg españa